I have a confession to make. I am exercising my right to not finish a book. This is a right I have used not very often in my lifetime. I am always compelled to know how a book ends, but all the distractions from aspects I didn't care for stifled that desire in me for now. After I was about one hundred pages in, I just couldn't do it anymore.
The story in this book is no doubt amazing and suspenseful. It just wasn't for me though. I am a little picky about an author's style when reading a book. I just don't like the way Wein writes I think. I also found it a little hard to follow. I couldn't imagine being a middle school student trying to read this book. I wonder if maybe it would be better used for high school students or even adults. I was fascinated by the story, and I am going to try to finish it, maybe even next week over Spring Break. I just felt like it wasn't something I could read over a few days or even a week. It was almost so much to take in that I felt as if I needed a fairly long period of time to read it. I also felt like I was reading it rather slowly, another reason why I couldn't imagine giving it to a middle school student. My opinion may change after finishing the novel, but as of now, I'm not convinced that it's the most middle grades appropriate book. I guess you could say I am choosing to take a long break from the book rather than not finishing it. (Not finishing it is just too much for me to deal with perhaps). Although I don't enjoy the author's style and am not sure of the appropriateness for age level, I would still offer it to my students if I found out it was readable for middle school students. I look forward to hearing what you and my classmates who read it (or tried to) have to say tomorrow. I also look forward to trying to finish it if for nothing else than the challenge of finishing a book that presents a style that is not my favorite and a little confusing.
I appreciate your candor about not finishing - this is a great opportunity to learn about yourself as a reader and think about this situation as a teacher. What would you do if you had a student who exercised their right not to finish a book you were all reading? Interesting to think about....
ReplyDelete